Enroll in Medicare Supplement Health Insurance

Wisconsin Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans

Our Medicare Supplement Insurance plans offer personalized care from a large selection of physicians and specialists, plan options** and a simple claims process that reduces complex claims paperwork. Your local Sales Representative can explain your plan options. Contact yours today.

Can You Predict Your Future Health Needs? What are your TRUE costs?

As life returns to normal, unfortunately so will medical bills. If you have put off medical treatment in the last 18 months, it’s smart to double check what your true out of pocket expenses will be. Planning on traveling soon? Will you be covered out-of-network?

Catholic United Financial offers Medicare supplement plans designed to go hand-in-hand with your current Medicare coverage. Our plans will help fill the coverage gaps you may experience with basic Medicare and pay for the portions not covered, such as deductibles and co-pays.* 

Why buy from Catholic United?

Competitive Premium Pricing

Easy Enrollment Process

Hassle-Free Claims Service

No Teaser Rates or Rate Hikes

One Stop Shop for Plans

Honors Your Catholic Faith

With a history of strength spanning 140 years, Catholic United is a leader in supporting the Catholic community in the Upper Midwest. Our giving network is made up of members, local volunteers, and Catholic United employees who have helped raise millions of dollars for the Catholic communities of the Upper Midwest.

Need someone to talk to about enrolling, or a quote?

phone  1-800-568-6670

Call us
Mon-Thu: 8 am to 4:45 pm
Fri: 8 am to 12:30 pm

Medigap Home

Get a Quote

Learn about Medigap

Enroll in Medigap

in Minnesota
in Iowa
in North Dakota
in South Dakota
in Wisconsin

Medigap or Medicare Advantage

Attend a Workshop

Questions to Ask Yourself

Educational Videos

Medigap Links and Education

Billing and Claims Questions

For Policy Holders
For Providers

Medicare Supplement Health Insurance is underwritten by:
Catholic United Financial
Medicare Supplement Administrative Office
PO Box 27248, Salt Lake City, UT 84127-0248

Would you like a quote over the phone? Call us

Sales Representative Vicky Giacalone, FIC

Vicky Giacalone, FIC
Sales Representative

(920) 475-3196

Email Vicky

Serving Eastern Wisconsin, including Wausau, Green Bay, Milwaukee, Madison and nearby

Independent Agent Terry Quinn

Terry Quinn, FIC
Independent Agent

(651) 493-1437

Email Terry

Serving Hudson, River Falls, Somerset, Baldwin and nearby



Dean Demarais, FIC, LUTCF
Medicare Supplement Sales Manager

(800) 568-6670



Brenda Kraemer
Specialist – Medicare Supplement Insurance

(800) 568-6670


Chart of Available Medigap Plans

Click chart to enlarge

Source: Medicare.gov. 1Ask to review available policy’s outline of coverage details, specific benefits and limitations. 2“Coverage of the Part B deductible will no longer be available to people who are new to Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. However, if you were eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020 but not yet enrolled, you may be able to get this benefit.” From Medicare.gov: “Plans known as “50% and 25% Cost-sharing Plans” are available. These plans are similar to standardized Plans K (50%) and L (25%). A high-deductible plan ($2,340) is also available.” 

Learn about Medicare at our free workshops

In less than one hour, learn your best options for Medicare and Supplement Health insurance at this free workshop, sponsored by a financial services company that honors your Catholic faith. Learn these details about Medicare:

  • Who is eligible for coverage and where it is offered
  • Different plans and options
  • How to close any gaps in Medicare coverage
  • How where you live affects your options and pricing
  • Best times to enroll in a Medicare supplement insurance policy
  • And more...

Articles on Medicare Supplement Health Insurance

Medicare Annual Enrollment Period is Open Now Through Dec. 7th

It can be confusing to know what you can do during this time. We're here to help! 
Read More

What can you do during the annual open enrollment period?

If you're enrolled in Medicare, the annual enrollment period gives you options, but only through Dec. 7th.
Read More

Medicare Open Enrollment Period starts Oct. 15

Medicare Open Enrollment Period starts Oct. 15. Are you ready for this important period of time for Medicare change?
Read More
Medicare Specialist Tara Donohue Weiss explains Medicare Supplement policies and Medicare Advantage plans

Watch: Medicare and you in two minutes

Medicare specialist Tara Donahue-Weiss discusses Medigap insurance vs Medicare Advantage, which is the better fit for most people in the long run
Read More
COVID-19 Medicare scams to be aware of.

Answers to health coverage questions about COVID-19

Medicare and Medicare Supplement Health Insurance is available to help people cover expenses incurred due to the COVID-19 health crisis. Here are some answers to common questions about Medicare coverage during the pandemic.
Read More
Do you have a billing or claim question about your Medicare Supplement insurance?
Call 1-800-568-6670

Catholic United Financial and its Medicare Supplement insurance policy are not connected with or endorsed by the US Government or the federal Medicare program. Plan options vary depending on where you live. This is a solicitation of insurance. ©2022 Catholic United Financial

MSW919.8    Last update: 9/28/2021